Skip to main content

Are black cats unlucky? What you need to know

Maybe it’s their mysterious nature. Or perhaps it’s the intimidating way they hiss and arch their back when provoked. One thing is for certain: Black cats have a reputation shrouded in intrigue and innuendo. But is it warranted?

If you’ve ever purposely gone the other way just to make sure a black cat doesn’t cross your path or felt the hair on the back of your neck stand up at the sight of a black cat on Halloween night, you may be wondering the same thing.

Simply put, black cats don’t have the best reputation. They’ve been accused of bringing bad luck, of being witches in disguise, and of being co-conspirators in black magic, among other things. The rumors aren’t true, of course. So, in honor of National Black Cat Appreciation Day (August 17), here’s how the rumors got started and what you really need to know about these maligned animals.

black cat with green eyes on grass
Image used with permission by copyright holder

How did black cats get such a bad reputation, anyway?

Stories vary, but one popular version claims black cats’ bad rep began in Greek mythology. Evidently, Hera (Zeus’ wife) transformed her servant (Galinthias) into a black cat for spoiling her plan to interfere with the birth of Herakles. When Hecate, the goddess of witchcraft, took Galinthias in as her assistant, well … the whole black-cat-as-a-witch’s-sidekick thing was born.

Another explanation comes from Europe in the Middle Ages, where a father and son were rumored to have injured a black cat that crossed their path by throwing rocks at it. The cat took shelter from the attack with a woman who was rumored to be a witch. When the woman was seen, bruised and limping, the next day, locals assumed she was the black cat in disguise.

That encounter may have been the impetus for yet another myth that arose during the Great Plague, which killed an estimated 100,000 individuals in London. The bacterial infection was transmitted through the bite of a flea. As a result, as many as 40,000 dogs and 200,000 cats were killed because they were suspected of carrying the disease. Black cats, already scorned for their perceived sorcery, were now feared as plague-carrying grim reapers simply because they crossed the street in front of someone who would later perish from the plague.

And, of course, there’s that jet-black fur. The fact that it’s the same color as ravens and crows, which also have bad reputations, is just another strike against them.

So, are black cats unlucky?

Nope. In fact, owning a pet can actually make you healthier. In addition to the extra exercise pet owners get by playing with their furry friends, pet ownership lowers blood pressure, decreases stress, and combats loneliness by providing companionship.

Plus, think about how much value black cats lend the Halloween industry. Decorations of black cats with green eyes arching sinisterly alongside gruesomely carved jack-o’-lanterns and bowls of candy are a welcome sight for most treat-or-treaters. Black cat costumes are a favorite among young and old alike. With as many as 148 million consumers spending an estimated $8 billion on merchandise last year, black cats are definitely lucky for those in the business of selling Halloween.

So, as National Black Cat Appreciation Day approaches, maybe we should acquaint ourselves with myths that portray black cats as symbols of good luck. For example:

  • Lucky in love. Single ladies in Japan believe black cats attract potential suitors.
  • Safe travels. Sailors in Europe often brought along a black cat to ensure a safe journey (and to eat the mice on board).
  • A sign of prosperity. In Scotland, a stray cat that appears on your doorstep is a sign that great wealth is headed your way.
  • Black cats are divine. At least, that’s how the ancient Egyptians viewed them. They believed the gods lived within them.
  • Good luck charm. Brides in parts of England often received black cats as gifts to bring them luck in their marriage. The French believe some black cats are magical beasts (matagots) and that feeding them brings good luck.

happy woman with black cat

Why any cat makes a great pet

Of course, if you’re a cat owner, you already know that cats are great companions regardless of their color. Domesticated felines are quiet, low-maintenance, fiercely independent animals with a long life span. And despite their reputation for being mischievous, aloof, and strong-willed, the sound of contentment they make when they’re relaxed and happy is mentally and physically beneficial for anyone smart enough to curl up and listen.

Debbie Clason
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Debbie Clason's work has appeared in Family Life Magazine, Sports Illustrated, The Lutheran Witness, Massage Magazine…
7 incredible rare cat breeds you may never have heard of
These breeds are worth researching before adopting a new cat
A Chartreux cat with orange eyes

You probably remember the singing animated Siamese cats from Lady and the Tramp, and almost everyone has seen a stereotypical black cat at least once in life. These iconic kitties are as cute as can be, but they're also extremely recognizable. And there's nothing wrong with that! Domestic shorthairs and mixed-breed street cats are just as lovable as your fanciest purebred friends, but it's time to give rarer cat breeds their time in the spotlight.
These seven rare cat breeds are as unique as they come, and most of them we've never heard of before. From exotic-looking ancient breeds to relatively new hybrids, these kitties truly are one in a million. Who knew you could learn something new while looking at adorable cats? It's a win-win for everybody.

Chartreux cats are the national cats of France

Read more
Why do cats like being pet? (and where you should pet them)
This is the right way to pet a cat
A woman lies in bed petting her cat

Every cat owner has gone to pet their fur baby, only to get swatted in the face by their kitty. Sometimes, it can seem like cats don't enjoy affection at all. But while these finicky animals might prefer you pet them only on their terms, most cats do want pats from time to time, in the right places, of course. So why do cats like being pet? We'll walk you through where, how, and why to pet your four-legged feline friend.
Why do cats like being pet?

Like so many things, you need to understand their basic nature to have a better sense of why they yearn for your attention. Even in the wild, you might see cats groom and snuggle together, which has evolved into head scratches and belly rubs. Why else do kitties want you to stroke them? Here are four reasons.
It feels good
You may also spy your cat rolling on the carpet, lying in the sun, or licking their paws. While these actions can have practical reasons, for the most part, our beasties engage in the behaviors because they feel good. Cats can also be satisfied by a petting session from their human, and so they will look for you to fulfill this need.
They like you
It can be tricky to build trust with your pet, but once that's established, your cat will love to act affectionately toward you. You'll find them start to approach you more, perhaps rubbing against your legs or wanting to sit on or near you. Eventually, you'll graduate to outright petting and then they'll be asking for pats all the time.
You should smell like them
Many animals feel that their humans need to smell like them, which is a form of ownership to your mouser. Once you are scented just like your kitty, everyone will know that you're part of their group and belong to them. Cats also rub their bodies, and therefore pheromones, on things in your household, like your bed or your clothes, for the same reasons.
They want attention
We all crave attention sometimes — even our elusive cats. When they want you to notice them, it could be as a result of boredom or anxiety, but they also might just want you to dote on them, as they deserve. You'll soon pick up on your sweet pet's personal preferences and get a good feeling for when they want some love.
Why don't some cats like petting?

Read more
Decoding cat tail language: Why cats shake their tails
What your cat is trying to tell you by shaking their tail
A light-colored cat tail against a dark, carapeted floor

The idea that a cat's tail can tell a tale isn't just a fun play on words. Kitties speak to us through vocalizations (like purrs and growls) and body language. A cat's tail can let us know they're happy or even stressed to the max.

A wagging tail is often a sign of happiness in the dog world. Cats are a different animal, though. Don't speak cat tail language? You may be concerned or curious about why your cat's tail is shaking. The truth? A quivering tail is only one piece of the puzzle in decoding your cat's mood and health. These insights will take you through common reasons a cat's tail shakes and other clues to help you pinpoint which one applies to your pet.
Learn cat tail language: Why do cats shake their tails?

Read more