Skip to main content

3 great homemade cat treat recipes to make in October

Feeding your cat store-bought cat treats is easy and convenient, but there are so many great flavors in October that your cat doesn’t get in a commercially prepared treat. If you’re doing some cooking and baking for your family, why not create some homemade cat treats for your kitty, too? These three recipes feature tasty fall flavors like pumpkin and turkey, and they’re an extra-special way to show your cat how much you love him. When you make treats at home, you know exactly what goes into them, and you know they’re free of preservatives and additives. These three recipes are the purr-fect choice to make this October.

Hand feeding a cat a treat while the cat puts its paw on the hand
Andriy Blokhin / Adobe Stock

Healthy cat treats

Pumpkin spice cat treats

Now, your cat can enjoy special pumpkin treats while you’re carving your jack-o’-lanterns. These pumpkin spice treats require only four ingredients: pumpkin puree, cooked turkey or turkey cat food, oat flour, and catnip. You’ll blend all the ingredients together and then prepare the treats to go into the oven.

You have two options for how you cook the treats. You can spoon them onto parchment paper in tiny drops, or you can spread them thinly to create more of a snap treat. This crunchy texture might be extra appealing to your cat.

Homemade pumpkin cat treats

These homemade treats aren’t only tasty, but they’re good for your cat, too. They feature seasonal pumpkin, as well as oats, salmon, egg, and avocado for plenty of nutrition.

The recipe is easy to make. You’ll need a blender so you can blend the oats until they’re a fine meal. Then, you just add the rest of the ingredients and create small treats. Bake the treats, and you’re done. Your cat will have an extra-special treat that’s a healthy choice.

These healthy cat treats keep for only 3 to 4 days when stored in the fridge, so you’ll want to use them up quickly or give some to all your friends who have cats.

Super-easy three-ingredient treats

October can get pretty busy between getting ready for Halloween, picking apples and pumpkins, and going to harvest festivals. That’s why this three-ingredient recipe is a great choice. It’s super easy to make, using an egg, flour, and a can of your cat’s favorite Fancy Feast pâte. To dress the treats up a little, you can even incorporate some of your cat’s favorite vegetable, like pumpkin, or some cranberries for extra texture.

Preparing these treats is quick and simple. Just combine the ingredients in a bowl, roll them out, cut them, and bake them. You can use a cookie cutter or snip the treats into little pieces for perfect portions. They’ll keep for up to 2 weeks in an airtight container.

A cat stretching up to eat a treat out of a person's hand
Jaromir Chalabala/Shutterstock

Tips for successful treats

When making these treats for your cat, be sure to follow the recipes closely but choose flavors your cat loves. If a recipe calls for turkey, but you know your cat adores chicken, make the swap. It will make the treats more appealing and increase the chances of your cat appreciating all your hard work by eating the treats.

Before you bake any of these treats, think carefully about the size that’s best for your cat. A treat that’s too big might not cook through, and it could be difficult for your cat to eat. Smaller treats are usually better, especially since you can feed small amounts of them at a time. You might have luck finding a mini cookie cutter so you can quickly cut appropriately sized treats.

For even and thorough baking, try to make all the treats the same size. You might need to rotate the cookie sheet halfway through baking.

With these homemade cat treats, your cat can enjoy the flavors of fall, and you can include all his favorite foods, too. It might be tempting to give your cat lots of treats, especially if he loves them, but it’s important to give your cat only a few treats at a time. New foods in large volumes can upset his digestive system, and just like food, treats add calories into your cat’s diet. Feeding too many treats might fill your cat up, too, so he’s less likely to eat his food, which is balanced to ensure he gets the nutrition he needs. Feed treats as additions to your cat’s diet, but don’t go overboard. Plus, feeding just a few at a time will keep your cat looking forward to the next treat feeding time.

Paige Cerulli
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Paige's work has appeared in American Veterinarian, Business Insider, Healthline, and more. When she's not writing, Paige…
Why do cats like earwax? This curious habit explained
Find out about this curious feline behavior
A woman and cat lying on a bed

Cats are curious creatures. Sometimes, you may wonder, "Is this the end for me?" as your kitty saunters toward you. Yet, you find out your cat very much would like to keep you around — and use you for your earwax. You may have heard cats adore going ham on holiday trees and go bananas for tuna. A love of earwax? That one probably was missing from your bingo card. Yet, here we are.

Plot twist: Many cats have a thing for earwax, but why? What gives? Why do cats like earwax? Also, some items like indoor plants are toxic to cats. Is earwax? These questions are all good ones. We dug up some answers, including why cats like earwax and when to be concerned.
Why do cats like earwax?

Read more
Do cats really get ‘high’ on catnip or are they just being goofy?
Your feline loves this 'kitty drug' and it's mostly safe for them
Gray and white cat eating catnip out of a plastic bottle

Many cats go absolutely crazy for catnip, sometimes called a kitty drug. While catnip isn't a drug in the traditional sense, it can prompt some pretty crazy behavior from your cat. Many cats get super-excited and start racing around the house or playing crazily. Others tend to go into a very relaxed, almost sedated state.

While these behaviors might prompt us to think that our cats are high, that's not exactly what's going on. Understanding the question: "Why do cats like catnip?" and the effect that it has on your cat can help you to see just what's going on when you give your cat his favorite catnip toy.
Do cats get high on catnip?

Read more
8 reasons why your cat won’t stop rolling around
If you spy your kitty rolling around, this is what could be behind it
A long-haired cat rolls around on a brown carpet

Cats are famous for their chaotic personalities and unpredictable behaviors, but one of the most random things they can do is roll around on the floor. Most of the time, it seems to come out of nowhere. It's one thing to watch a sleepy feline lie down for a catnap in the sun, but it's another thing entirely when they flop over with all of their might.
While there's no doubt that it's entertaining to watch, not all cat owners or admirers know what's behind this silly-looking behavior. Why do cats roll around? Even though it may look like they're scratching themselves on the ground or asking for belly rubs like a dog, there are several real explanations ranging from obvious to subtle. At least now you'll know.

Why do cats roll around?

Read more