Skip to main content

PawTracks may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Is homemade cat litter an effective alternative?

Handling cat litter is probably every pet owner’s least-favorite part of having a cat. Not only is it stinky and messy, but it also can cost a fortune to buy every month. When browsing all the different types of litter on the market, many cat owners start to wonder if it’s possible to make homemade cat litter. Natural materials, like baking soda and newspapers, are easy to come by; how hard could it be? Homemade cat litter can be an effective alternative, though it’s not without its drawbacks. Read on below to learn more about switching to handmade cat litter, its pros and cons, and what materials you need to get started.

Is homemade cat litter effective?

As long as you use the proper materials, there is no reason why you can’t make your own cat litter. It’s perfectly safe for your cat to use homemade litter. It provides them with a clean spot to cover their waste, just like store-bought litters do. Plus, many of the materials companies use to make litter, like newspaper and sawdust, are readily available for you to use in your DIY litter.

But remember, cats can be stubbornly finicky, even when it comes to their litter. If they don’t like the kind you want them to use, they will let you know (keep those slippers out of reach!). It may take some trial and error before you find a litter option that your cat will use. Put out a few boxes with different litter formulas in them to see which one your cat is drawn to.

Benefits and disadvantages of homemade litter

Before you decide to forgo store-bought litter forever, consider the advantages and drawbacks of making cat litter.

Pros

  • Cost: Buying commercial cat litter every few weeks starts to add up quickly. You can save some money by using materials you have around your home or buying them from a store.
  • Sustainability: Companies use strip mining to obtain the clay used to make cat litter, destroying wildlife and their habitats. To reduce your environmental impact, you can prepare your own litter with natural materials and eco-friendly methods.
  • Emergencies: Nobody in your home will be happy if you unexpectedly run out of litter. When an emergency arises, it’s often easier to make your own than to run out to the store and hope they have it in stock.
  • Health concerns: Some types of cat litters, especially those made with clay, can contain carcinogens. These can trigger an allergic reaction or asthma in some cats.

Cons

  • Picky cats: As mentioned, cats are notoriously picky, and they may not like your homemade cat litter. If you have a fussy cat, it may not be worth the trouble and the mess to switch her to a different type of litter.
  • Time-consuming: Some DIY cat litters can take a lot of time to make, like ones made of shredded newspaper. If you’re busy, it may make more sense to buy it from a store.
  • Smell: Store-bought litters contain deodorizers to help mask the scent of your pet’s waste. While adding baking soda can help, it may not be strong enough to stop odors from permeating your home.

What to use to make litter

Crumpled up newspaper
Savvapanf Photo/Shutterstock

If you decide to go the homemade route, you will have plenty of different materials to choose from. One of the most popular choices is shredded newspaper and other unwanted paper. While stores sell newspaper-based litters, you can save some money by making your own. First, you’ll need to cut the paper into strips and soak them in soapy water to remove all the ink. Drain the water and soak the paper again with clean water until the strips are crumbly. Let the crumbles dry out completely, and voilà, you have your own cat litter.

It is also safe to use materials like sawdust, chicken feed, ground whole wheat, alfalfa pellets, or sand for cat litter. In fact, before commercial cat litter was created in 1947, many cat owners used sand for litter with indoor cats. Most of these materials can be found around the home, at animal or farm supply stores, or, for sawdust, at a local woodworking shop.

One of the biggest problems with homemade litter is odor control. Especially in multi-cat homes, DIY litter may not be strong enough to keep smells in one place. Luckily, there are things you can add to your homemade litter to solve this problem. Add baking soda, cedar chips, or a litter-specific deodorizing product to your mixture before putting it in the litter box to absorb any odors.

Whether you’re in a pinch or are trying to live a greener lifestyle, switching to homemade litter can be a great option. DIY cat litter is safe, effective, and cost-efficient. Plus, there are many different materials you can use to make it. However, the choice is ultimately up to your cat. After all, she’s the one who actually has to use it. Hopefully, the advice above will help you decide whether you want to make the change to homemade cat litter.

Topics
Shannon Cooper
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Shannon Cooper has written about everything from pet care and travel to finance and plumbing in her seven years as a writer…
This is why your cat throws up after eating (and when it’s a problem)
Should my cat be throwing up after eating? Here's when to be concerned
A cat licking lips after eating from white bowl

We can't read minds or speak Cat, but our furry friends give us clues into their well-being (and thoughts) through behaviors and habits. For instance, yes, your cat is chirping at birds because they want to head outside for a hunt. You can take Kitty out of the wild but you can't take the wild out of your contemporary sofa lion.

As much as your cat's desire to snag a bird may make you question their otherwise kind demeanors, other behaviors are less expected, such as if your cat throws up after eating. Is this normal? An inherited trait from wild ancestors (wolves and coyotes regurgitate food to feed their young)? Good questions. Here's what to know about and what to do if your cat throws up after eating.
Why do cats throw up so much?

Read more
Why do cats have whiskers? The answer is more in-depth than you think
Cat whiskers serve many purposes on top of cuteness
Sokoke cat on a gray background

If you already love cats, then you'll be one of the first to tell everyone you know how cute they are. From their bright eyes and adorable ears to their whiskers and expressive tails, cats are undoubtedly one of the most precious creatures to walk the planet. But did you know there's actually a scientific reason we think cats are cute?

In fact, science can explain just about everything these days, including one of life's greatest cat-related mysteries. A cat's whiskers are one of its defining characteristics, but have you ever wondered, "Why do cats have whiskers?" We're here to give you the full scoop. 
What are whiskers?

Read more
7 big cat breeds that make great pets
Big cats are almost a totally different animal and will change your pet-owning experience
Maine Coon cat lying on bed

Everyone knows about dog breeds, but some first-time cat owners might not realize that felines have unique breeds, too. Many of the cats you've seen are probably domestic shorthair, by far the most common variety. However, every now and then, you might stumble on a cat that looks extra large and wonder what's different about him. Tt turns out, they could be an entirely unique kind of cat.

While big cats can require some specialized care, they also come along with outsized personalities to match. If you're looking for more cat to love, try out one of these big cat breeds.
What are the most popular large cat breeds?

Read more