Skip to main content

Bringing home a second dog: 8 strategies for a smooth introduction

Tips to help with this important process

Two pit bull dogs jump and play outside in a grassy yard
David Taffet / Unsplash

If you’re considering getting a second dog — congratulations! Deciding when you’re ready to add four new paws to the family is a big step, and you’re not alone if you waited longer than you liked before getting your dog a friend. Some pet parents need to save up or move to a bigger home before they can adopt a dog, but this is a responsible thing to do in the long run. Even so, most of the work still lies ahead of you.

It can be another long process to find and adopt the right dog for you, but then you’ll need to learn how to get dogs to get along. It’s not exactly a straightforward or short process. There’s no one-size-fits-all approach to introducing two dogs, either, but these tips will always come in handy, no matter what step of the process you’re on. Take a deep breath (you’ve got this!) and keep reading to learn more.

Recommended Videos

1. Know what kind of dog you and your family are looking for

Two dogs sit in grass
Caleb Carl / Unsplash

The first step to ensuring a successful introduction between two dogs happens long before they actually meet. You’ll want to think carefully and do your research when selecting the right dog to bring home because not every pup you meet will be a good match.

Of course, you can talk to animal shelter staff to find a dog that’s friendly with other pups, but it’s up to you to ensure you have the space, time, and resources to care for whichever dog you pick. You’ll want to consider what your future dog’s routines and activity levels will look like at home to make sure you select a dog breed that meshes well with your home, too.

2. Have two of everything on hand

A man walks two Siberian Huskies in a neighborhood
Wasitt Hemwarapornchai / Shutterstock

Even if both your current dog and your new pup have shown no signs of resource guarding, it will make everyone’s life easier to have two of everything on hand. This will ensure that both dogs can drink if they’re thirsty at the same time and that they won’t be competing for their favorite bones and dog toys. This will help your dogs avoid any early disagreements, and it will prevent your current dog from feeling like their new roommate is taking food out of their mouths (literally and figuratively).

3. Leave your current dog at home when meeting your new furry friend

Two dogs chewing on the same stick
Alexas_Fotos / Pixabay

Even though it may sound smart to bring your furry friend with you while searching for a new sibling, it’s probably best to leave them at home when you initially meet. This will allow you to give 100% of your attention to the rescue dogs in front of you so you can make a huge decision: Which is the dog for you?

Bringing your current dog to an animal shelter could be chaotic for you, overwhelming for your dog, and triggering for any reactive pups in the shelter. If you’re ready to schedule a meet-and-greet with a new pup, the shelter workers will guide you through the process. Many require the entire family to meet a dog before taking them home, but there’s no single right way to set up these introductions.

4. Enlist the help of a second person for introductions

Two curly haired dogs sit next to each other in front of a brick wall
Sam Lion / Pexels

Speaking both logically and from experience, it can be next to impossible to handle an introduction between two dogs on your own. It’s always a smart idea to have both pups on a loosely held leash while meeting, but that can be so hard when you’re alone! This could add a lot of stress to the situation, which never helps.

Even if both dogs have perfectly clean histories, it’s also essential to have at least one person for every dog in the area in case of a fight. It’s better to be safe than sorry.

5. Introduce your dogs while on a walk in a neutral area

Two cute curious Chihuahua dogs wearing fashion knitted clothes sitting together outdoors
Irina Nedikova / Getty Images

While most animal shelters conduct introductions in a fenced-in yard, it can be even better to walk the dogs side by side in a larger area like a park. This can feel a lot less tense and intimidating than meeting face to face in a small space, which they can interpret as a confrontation.

It’s also important to introduce dogs outside of the home or any spaces where your current dog may feel territorial. Once they’re interacting, or at least coexisting comfortably, you can move to your home.

6. Don’t force dogs to interact

A Beagle and a Westie sit in grass facing one another
Hilary Halliwell / Unsplash

It can be tough to know how to get dogs to get along, but the truth is that your dogs might be feeling just as clueless. Rescue dogs in their new homes may feel overwhelmed or exhausted after spending time in the shelter, so don’t force dogs to interact before they’re ready to. As long as neither dog is acting aggressively while walking side by side in a neutral place, you can still bring both dogs into your home.

7. Feed separately until they’re more comfortable

A tan dog cuddling a gray dog in bed.
Adrianna Calvo / Pexels

It may be annoying and time consuming to feed your dogs separately, but that can keep meal times low key and relaxing while everyone gets used to the new home dynamic. It can reduce opportunities for competition and resource guarding, which will keep things friendly and positive. You can start by feeding treats at the same time,  then feeding them at opposite ends of the room, but some multi-dog households always have to feed their pups separately. Whatever works!

8. Supervise playtime at the beginning

Two dogs meeting
yulana / Shutterstock

The worst-case scenario is that you’ll need to stop two dogs from fighting, but this is likely to have a better outcome than if two dogs that don’t get along are left alone. This is why it’s so important to supervise playtime, especially during the first few weeks when dogs are still learning each other’s play styles and body language.

Most dogs figure this out on their own with a few barks and growls, but it’s always smart to stick around at first. A puppy that wants to play could mistakenly anger an older dog that’s sleepy or in pain, but you can redirect them both before they escalate their argument.

This may sound like a lot to consider – -and at first, it is — but with a little time and patience, your whole family will wonder how you ever lived without your newest furry friend. It will be worth the effort!

Gabrielle LaFrank
Gabrielle LaFrank has written for sites such as Psych2Go, Elite Daily, and, currently, PawTracks. When she's not writing, you…
What you need to know about dogs with blue eyes
Blue eyes are a rarity that may come with some health risks
Upside down brown dog with blue eyes

Blue-eyed dogs are striking, both because of their vivid irises and because of how rare they are. After all, even though most puppies are born with blue eyes (their irises haven't developed melanin yet), most of them experience eye color changes around 1 month old. And while there’s almost nothing sweeter than staring into the brown eyes of an adoring pet, those dog breeds with blue eyes are, well, a sight to behold.

Whether you're lucky enough to have a blue-eyed dog or are just curious about these gorgeous dogs, read on to discover what causes this beautiful abnormality. We’ll share which dog breeds naturally have blue eyes, why that occurs, and if blue-eyed dogs are at risk for health problems as a result.
What dog breeds have blue eyes?

Read more
This is where dogs like to be pet: The spots they can’t resist
These are the top places to pet your dog (and the ones to avoid)
A woman pets her dog in a field

One of the best parts of owning a dog is providing pats, scritches, and belly rubs. Our buds seem to love this as much as we do, and research says that petting a pooch gives a mood boost to both humans and animals. Even though we know that pups love pats, we should still respect their boundaries and only touch them in the areas they like. While every fur baby has personal preferences, we'll cover the common areas where dogs like to be pet.
Why dogs like to be pet

About 20,000 years ago, dogs decided they preferred hanging out with humans for nourishment rather than hunting their own food. Along the way, we became more than just a meal ticket to them, and now most dogs are solely companions (of course, many still work demanding jobs as service animals or alongside police officers).

Read more
Adopting a dog? 6 things no one tells you
How to help your newly adopted dog adjust smoothly
A woman in a brown sweater holding a sleeping black and white French bulldog puppy

It's no secret that adopting a dog can change your life for the better. You'll spend more time outdoors taking your dog for walks, so you'll get plenty of exercise. Having a constant companion helps combat feelings of isolation and sadness, and taking on the responsibility of caring for another living being builds character.

More importantly, adopting a new dog from a shelter saves a sweet, innocent animal from euthanasia and helps fight puppy mills. But having a dog isn't always a walk in the park. From unexpected expenses to puppy proofing your home, here are some things to know before adopting a dog. 
1. You're going to spend a lot of time outside — no matter the weather

Read more