Skip to main content

5 useful tips from the experts to stop a dog’s excessive guarding

As much as we treat our dogs like family members, there are times when they remind us in no uncertain terms that they are, indeed, animals. If your dog is growling, snarling, or baring his teeth whenever you come near his favorite possession or person, you’ve been reminded.

For the record, he’s exhibiting a behavior known as resource guarding, an instinctively protective response dogs use to keep others away from those things they consider valuable. This can be anything from their food bowl or favorite toy to a specific person or place to sleep. Although this can be disheartening at the very least, it’s not uncommon. Here’s how experts recommend you stop it.

man in blue shirt with dog in lap
Image used with permission by copyright holder

What causes this behavior?

“Guarding is actually an incredibly natural thing for dogs,” Ali Smith, founder of Rebarkable, says. “Dogs will guard things they find valuable or are worried will run out, but the approach [for stopping it] depends on what it is.”

Smith, who moved from just outside London, England, to Maryland, champions force-free training methods and is passionate about helping her clients understand their dog so the pups are more capable of being a confident and adaptable family member.

Tips for stopping excessive guarding

Although guarding is instinctive, it’s important to teach your pup how to mind his manners to keep him from becoming too aggressive.

Start training when they are young

Dr. Heather Venkat, a companion animal veterinarian since 2013, lifelong pet owner, and consultant/writer for VIP Puppies, recommends pet parents begin working with their dogs when they are puppies to prevent excessive guarding behavior.

“Dogs may excessively guard because whenever someone approaches, their resource is taken away,” she says, “so pet parents should not always approach their dog just to take away their toy, chew bone, or food. They should pet their dog or touch their bowl or toy and reward him/her for being calm.”

Discourage the habit at the onset

Venkat said once a dog realizes its growling, snapping, or barking keeps humans and other animals away from their valuables, they will continue the behavior, so begin corrective measures as soon as this tendency becomes apparent.

This is especially true if your dog is exceptionally protective of one person in the family. While it might seem cute to have your small lapdog growl and snap at anyone who tries to sit beside you on the couch, it’s important for him to learn that behavior is not acceptable:

  • Encourage your dog to form positive relationships with other humans.
  • Create clear boundaries by teaching him to stay off the furniture or removing him from your lap and calmly setting him on the floor when the guarding behavior begins.
  • Invest in obedience training and practice asking your dog to follow the commands so he develops a healthy respect for you.
black and white puppy with yellow pig toy
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Redirect the behavior

Sometimes changing this behavior is as simple as managing the situation in which your dog exhibits guarding tendencies.

For example, Smith says, if there are multiple dogs in the family and one guards their dinner bowl from the others, the suggestion is to feed the dogs in separate rooms.

If your dog guards the bed from your partner, she recommends a twofold solution that includes working to improve the relationship between your dog and your partner and creating a space for your dog that is not your bed.

If you notice guarding behavior while your dog is playing with a toy or chewing on his favorite bone, call him into another room and reward his obedience with a treat or a different toy. Then, calmly  return to the first room and remove the object he was guarding.

“That may feel like you’re not training, but management is a huge part of training,” Smith says.

Work with a professional trainer

Of course, if your dog has threatened or bitten another person or family pet, it’s time to get professional help. Venkat recommends working with a professional dog trainer or veterinary behaviorist who can prescribe a clear treatment regimen of both behavior modification and sometimes even supplements or medication.

Remain calm and be consistent

Last but not least, remember that your attitude is an important part of changing your dog’s excessive guarding behavior. Practice positive reinforcement with this and other behavior modification practices. Using force can amplify any feelings of fear or frustration your dog may be feeling, which is exactly the behavior you’re trying to avoid. Be firm, show leadership, and create a safe, loving environment for your dog.

“The most important thing is for pet parents to remain calm, be consistent, and be patient while working through their dog’s excessive guarding issue,” Venkat says.

Editors' Recommendations

Debbie Clason
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Debbie Clason's work has appeared in Family Life Magazine, Sports Illustrated, The Lutheran Witness, Massage Magazine…
This video proves the dog pool is better than the dog park
Your pups could enjoy a dog pool day just like the ones in this video
A dog runs on a pool deck after a swim

If you're a pup parent, you've probably spent some time at the dog park, but have you ever given the dog pool a shot? As you might imagine, this takes the concept of the dog park and brings water into the equation. As this video proves, there's nothing cuter than watching a stream of pooches dive right into the water to play. It's truly a sight worth seeing.

This TikTok proves dog pool day can beat dog park day and is perfectly titled "Pool Day for the Pups." It opens on a shot of a big fenced-in pool with some buddies waiting excitedly outside. Once the gate is open, they pour in to start splashing in the water, swimming around, and, of course, barking madly. The welcoming setup even has some helpful mats on the edges to assist anyone with slippery feet getting in and out. A quick cut shows us another dog pool, this one indoors and filled with toys to help the happy games along. Again the furry friends make a mad dash in to play. It's clear that every single pup in the video is living their best life.

Read more
Are tennis balls bad for dogs? Here’s what you want to know before your next game of fetch
You should be asking this crucial question
Jack Russel terrier on the beach with a tennis ball jumping

When you think about classic dog toys, tennis balls are sure to make the list. They’re a fun, cheap option that many pet parents can stock up on just as quickly as their dog goes through them, which is good news for pups who like to chew or fetch. Still -- despite the balls' everlasting popularity -- more and more dog owners have stopped to wonder: Are tennis balls bad for dogs?
It can be difficult to guarantee the safety of any pet product, so you should pay special attention to your pup while he's playing with anything you don’t completely trust. Better yet, you can even research the items your dog is playing with. This could, and perhaps should, include low-quality dog toys or any chew item not meant for canines -- including tennis balls. Here’s what you need to know.

Should dogs play with tennis balls? Pros and cons of these popular dog toys
Although there are many pros to playing with tennis balls (they're cheap, easy to find, etc.), they come with many risks you may not have considered. The team at Animal Dental Care and Oral Surgery — or Wellpets, as its site is named — has put together some helpful reminders about the silent dangers of tennis balls.

Read more
7 of the most loyal small dog breeds for you and your family, ranked
These are the most affectionate and devoted small dog breeds
A woman holds a black and brown Chihuahua in her arms

While there’s no question that dogs and loyalty go hand in hand, small dogs are more often known for their sass. It’s not hard to picture an ankle-biter barking up a storm at any bigger dog who walks by, but when it comes to their people, these pint-sized pups couldn’t be more loyal. Whether this loyalty looks more like affection, protection, or just being nearby depends on the breed and the individual dog, so it’s worth considering what you’re truly looking for before you adopt a certain breed of dog. With any of the breeds on this list, though, you can’t go wrong.
These are the seven most loyal small dog breeds — ranked in order of loyalty. Of course, this came down to our research and beliefs, so you may have a different opinion. We'd love to know what you think--which do you think are the most loyal small dog breeds?

Shih tzus are lap dogs through and through -- they are the definition of loyalty
Shih tzus were bred to be companion dogs in Tibetan monasteries, in case you couldn't tell from their clingy personality. When you bring one of these affectionate pups into your home, explains Dr. Marty Goldstein, you’re signing up for one of the closest bonds you’ll ever make. They’ll be happy as your “Velcro dogs” no matter what you’re up to, and with their curious yet calm personalities, you’ll be happy to include them. Loyalty is just one reason to love this adorable, ancient breed.

Read more