Skip to main content

Is it cheaper to make your own dog food? What you need to consider before making the switch

Nothing is more comforting than a home-cooked meal, so why should humans get to have all the fun? If you’ve been looking into all the facts regarding homemade dog food, you need to consider each crucial factor before you transition your dog from a store-bought to a home-cooked diet. You might have been wondering whether you can actually create a healthier, more personalized concoction for your dog. And the answer is yes. Yes, you can assemble your very own dog food at home, saving you trips to the store in lieu of healthier, fresher food. But is making dog food cheaper than buying it? Let’s find out about preparing dog food at home and how costs compare.

British Bull Dog Eating from Dog Bowl
Monkey Business Images / Shutterstock

How do you make your own dog food?

Before making a choice as to whether making your own dog food is cheaper than buying it, it’s important to know what ingredients and supplies are needed to make dog food. What’s great about homemade dog food is that it can be personalized just to you and your dog’s needs. So, while exact ingredients will vary, dog food made at home typically contains some combination of cooked protein, vegetables, and whole grains.

Note that just like commercially-produced dog food, homemade dog food must have certain nutrients in order for your dog to maintain a healthy, balanced diet.

  • Popular, nutrient-dense proteins often used in homemade dog foods are ground lean beef, turkey, and lentils.
  • Among the vegetables you might use are broccoli, carrots, and sweet potatoes.
  • And some of the whole grains that are commonly found in dog food made at home are brown rice, oatmeal, and quinoa.
  • Fruits, herbs, and healthy fats should also be added in moderation in dog food.

No matter what foods you cook together to make meals for your dog, there are a few health and safety guidelines you should keep in mind. Dogs have different nutritional requirements than humans do. But similar to humans, junk foods are also unhealthy for dogs and should not be fed to them. It is important that your dog is only ever fed unseasoned, thoroughly-cooked, boneless meats. Many spices that are fine for humans can be dangerous or even deadly to dogs. The same goes for a variety of other human foods, so before throwing any random ingredient into home-cooked dog food, do your research as to whether it is safe for dogs to consume. Bones might splinter inside of a dog, causing internal injury. Uncooked or undercooked meats may carry bacteria or viruses that can cause illness.

If you want to obtain more facts in relation to dog food concerns, do check out our guide regarding your dog’s tolerance for spicy food — just so you’re better informed before chucking that chili his way.

dog eating out of dog food bowl
Kabo/Unsplash

How do the costs of homemade and commercial dog food compare?

There is a wide range of costs associated with both home-cooked and mass-produced dog foods, largely based on quality. A 40-pound bag of dry kibble could run you $15, while that same sized bag of high-quality food could cost closer to $75. Wet dog food costs more, with the cheapest single-serving cans costing less than $1 and higher-end cans costing up to $3 each. However, this is excluding the cost of bones, treats, dental sticks, vitamin supplements, and other types of food you might give your dog throughout the day.

And the price of homemade dog food is also dependent on where you shop, as well as if you buy organic or not. But, generally, you can get the cost of it down to lower than $2 a day, which is far beneath the cost of feeding your dog a mixture of high-quality wet and dry foods.

Woman buying dog food
VLG/Getty Images

How do I decide whether to make the switch to homemade dog food or not?

As with any choice, you should weigh the pros and cons of each option. Commercial dog foods are required by law to meet certain nutrition standards, so when you purchase commercial dog food, you know your dog is getting all of the vitamins, minerals, and macronutrients they need.

Conversely, commercial dog food often contains preservatives and fillers that aren’t needed in freshly-prepared dog food. Plus, if your dog has health conditions, they may need particular combinations of nutrients or ingredients that just can’t be found in a commercial product. And if your dog has allergies to any common dog food ingredients, it might be easier for you to make dog food for them. But before making a decision, consult with your veterinarian as to your pet’s health and what types of homemade dog food, if any, are suitable to feed them.

Keeping your dog healthy doesn’t have to be frustrating. It is possible to feed them nutritious, delicious, home-cooked meals at a fraction of the price of commercially-made foods. Enjoy experimenting with the many recipes you can use if you go that route!

Editors' Recommendations

PawTracks
Why do dogs get eye boogers? What you need to know about this common problem (and when you should be concerned)
Eye boogers are rarely serious but sometimes can indicate an infection
Closeup of dog eye

Eye boogers: The truth is that we all get them. At least both humans and our canine companions. Nearly everyone will experience this at some point in pet parenthood (human parenthood as well, usually), and it's certainly nothing to worry about most of the time.

Standard eye discharge doesn't mean a dog eye infection, but the two can be linked. We'll go through when this isn't an issue and what to look for to figure out if there's more going on. Here's everything you need to know about puppy eye goop.

Read more
Why do dogs eat cat poop? And how you can get them to stop
These tips will stop your pup from eating cat doo-doo
Dog wears a yellow sweater and looks at the camera

Sometimes you might think you hear your cat using their potty, but when you go into check, it's actually the dog eating cat poop. Gross! While it seems pretty revolting to us, dogs sometimes eat poop, the feline variety included. Coprophagia, which means eating poop, shows up reasonably frequently in pups, and certain diets, environments, and even breeds can make this act more likely (research says hounds and terriers are the groups most likely to chomp poop, in general).

So why do dogs eat cat poop, and what should you do about this behavior? Read on for a few things to check and a couple of tips to prevent this extra meal.
Why do dogs eat cat poop?
Theories abound, but it turns out lots of different mammals eat poop, their own and others'. One possibility is that not all nutrients fully digest when they go through our systems, which means there are plenty of vitamins to have by consuming feces. Sometimes, these cravings result from a nutrient-deficient diet that is easy to fix by changing up your dog's food.

Read more
Do dogs know they’re dying? Here’s what experts say about a dog’s final days
This is what a dog's last days might look like
A woman hugs and kisses her senior dog

No one wants to think about their dog’s final moments, but it’s an inevitable part of life that every pet parent will have to face. Hopefully, though, knowing what to expect can replace some of the fear and uncertainty with a sense of peace. Thinking through this life transition may be emotionally taxing, but asking the important questions (such as, do dogs know they’re dying? Do dogs fear death?) can make the process as easy as possible for everyone — especially you.

Take a deep breath, give your dog a little love, and scroll on if you’re feeling ready to learn about this important — yet difficult — time. We’ll let you know how to care for your senior dog, how your veterinarian will be helpful during this time, and what to expect as your dog's final moments draw near. Trust us — you're not in this alone.

Read more