Skip to main content

PawTracks may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

What’s the difference between fish and reptiles? The one key difference

There are many species in the animal kingdom, likely between 7 and 8 million in total. That means we share this Earth with countless others, most of whom look nothing like us (even though we’re fairly closely related in the grand scheme of things). Our nearest relatives are other vertebrates with backbones, like fish, reptiles, amphibians, mammals, and birds. So, what separates humans from frogs, or turtles from sharks? While these creatures do have some fundamentals in common, there are a number of characteristics that set each species apart. Knowing the difference between fish and reptiles will give you a better understanding of the natural world and your pets. 

Sea turtle swims next to fish in tropical water
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Are fish mammals or reptiles?

Actually, neither! It may be surprising to learn that fish are their own thing—more specifically, their own class. While humans, dogs, and even platypuses all belong to the mammal group, fish and reptiles each have unique traits that make them special. Most notably, mammals and birds are warm-blooded, while fish, reptiles, and amphibians are cold-blooded. That’s not where the similarities and differences end, though. 

How are fish, reptiles, and amphibians alike?

All of these creatures are ectotherms, or cold-blooded, which means they can’t produce their own heat. While our body temperatures stay at relatively the same level regardless of the weather, body temps for this crew fluctuate to reflect their environment. That’s why you need to keep it really warm in the cage for your bearded dragon or boa constrictor—reptiles frequently slip into hibernation when it gets too cold. You’ll also notice that none of these animals have feathers or fur. We need that layer to trap in the heat that we generate, but that would be counterproductive for a fish that gets its heat from the water.

How are fish, reptiles, and amphibians different?

For starters, each has a slightly different breathing system adapted for the habitat they live in. Fish live entirely underwater and breathe through gills (though a few noteworthy lungfish are able to breathe air). They’re also covered in scales and have fins instead of feet, all of which are designed to help streamline their swimming. Altogether, from head to tail, fish are meant to live their whole lives under the sea.

Then you have reptiles, which can live nearly their whole lives in the water, like a sea turtle. These animals only emerge to lay eggs on land. Unlike fish and amphibians, they have their babies on land, even if they’re water-dwelling. A few reptiles, such as desert snakes, have very little contact with water at all. That’s why almost all reptiles have thicker, scaly skin that’s not as suited to living underwater full time.

Amphibians fit in the middle because they spend the first part of their existence in the water with gills but then spend their adult life breathing air with lungs. Think about the way a tadpole transforms into an adult frog and you’ll understand what we mean.

Seahorse curls his tail under the water
Andrea Izzotti / Shutterstock

What do I need to know to take care of my reptile or fish?

Reptiles run the gamut of care and habitats. A turtle is very different from a snake, and both are very different from a crocodile. Because of this, your new pet will have very specific needs that vary greatly depending on the type of animal. Many lizards, turtles, tortoises, and even some snakes need lots of moisture, so some require constant misting or a bowl. Aquatic turtles spend nearly their whole lives in the water and only come up to bask and warm themselves. 

Most of us have a picture of what a fish looks like, but there are other animals that fit into this category, like seahorses and rays. Nearly all fish will want a full tank with plants and wonderful accessories. But just because they can breathe underwater doesn’t mean they don’t need oxygen—they do, and in spades. Make sure your filter provides enough fresh air to sustain all the life in your tank. 

You might look at a bearded dragon and then at your betta fish and not see a lot of similarities, but they actually have plenty in common. One key factor in all this is to keep your enclosures warm since your reptile or fish can’t generate their own heat. Otherwise, you might come to find them in a deep sleep if it gets cold. We recommend a thermometer and hygrometer for all the tanks you run. And all pet ownership requires dedication, love, and care for the beautiful creature who’s been entrusted to your care.

Editors' Recommendations

Rebekkah Adams
Rebekkah’s been a writer and editor for more than 10 years, both in print and digital. In addition to writing about pets…
What causes high pH in an aquarium? We’ll walk you through getting your tank levels in check
Try these 3 techniques to lower pH levels
Man working on aquarium

Keeping your pH consistent is a major part of a thriving aquarium. Too high or too low, and your whole ecosystem will be thrown out of whack. Generally speaking, the acceptable pH levels for an aquarium range from 6.8 to 7.8, with 7.0 being the neutral point. (Keep in mind your tank’s acidic or alkaline levels will go up and down pretty regularly, too.) What causes high pH in an aquarium? Here's the key information you need to know.

What is pH in Aquariums?
If you barely remember high school chemistry, you might be a little unclear about what pH even means and why it matters to your fish. First, know that we're actually looking at a measurement, which indicates the level of acidity or alkalinity of a liquid. Lower numbers mean more acidic and higher numbers, less.

Read more
Wondering what sharks are ideal for your home aquarium? These sharks fit right in
The best sharks for you to enjoy at home
Fish tank with aquatic plants

Without a doubt, sharks are the proverbial bad boys of the deep. Their antics have been the focus of major motion pictures, week-long television specials, and classic Rat Pack songs. Although we’re all used to seeing these creatures lurking in big bodies of water, we’ve found a few species that fit your fish tank. Yes, believe it or not, you really can keep sharks at home. First, you'll need to research and educate yourself on how to care for them. You'll also need to make sure you have the proper tank to accommodate them. If you're thinking of adding a shark to your tank, here are the ideal sharks for your home aquarium, as these breeds are small enough to fit.

Can I get a shark for my fish tank?
Yes, but they have stringent requirements and experts often recommend leaving shark caretaking for advanced hobbyists or professional aquariums. However, if you decide you're up to the challenge, you should prep first. A lot. The general rule of thumb says that the tank needs to be more than three times the length and two times the width of the (biggest) adult shark.

Read more
A simple guide to what to feed tadpoles in your aquarium
A list of everything you should and shouldn't give baby frogs
Small child looks into a jar of tadpoles

Whether you’re taking in rescue tadpoles or planning to keep frogs as pets, you’ll have to adapt continually to their changing bodies. These amphibians undergo a metamorphosis and live as tadpoles for up to 14 weeks, though the last stage of the transition happens in just 24 hours.

You’ll put them to bed as a kid and come back to a teenager. Also, tadpoles are vegetarians, but frogs are carnivorous, so you should prepare for their diet to evolve as they do over the course of a few months. Here's what to feed tadpoles.

Read more