Skip to main content

Do turtles make good pets? This one fact may make you reconsider

Some like dogs and some like cats, but there’s a whole other category of people who enjoy a different kind of pet. Sometimes it’s not a furry animal that completes your home, but a little something else. Birds, lizards, turtles, and snakes all can make perfect companions for the right person with the right setup. But don’t jump into reptile ownership without giving it a thorough examination first there’s a lot that is tricky about taking care of these creatures. As always, you need to research “turtles as pets” carefully, including the downsides, before you decide to become a Testudine parent.

Person strokes their pet turtle
Fernando Maté/Unsplash

What types of turtles make for good pets?

In order to choose the right little guy, you first need to make a big decision: land or sea? Of course, all turtles need some amount of water, but aquatic species live almost entirely in rivers or ponds while terrestrial species spend most of their time on the ground. From there you can narrow it down depending on the size of animal you want to keep and the conditions you feel able to maintain. Two common varieties that we recommend are the red-eared slider and the box turtle. You’ll still have choices to make as you’ll find variety when you go to the breeder or pet store to find your new shell-friend.

What does your pet turtle need to stay healthy?

Before you even bring your pet home, you’ll have to get a new enclosure ready for him. Exact needs vary by animal, but you’ll want a body of water, adequate substrate, a UV lamp, and a basking area. For an aquatic turtle, your tank will look more like an aquarium with a few good pieces of land that enable them to climb out and warm up in the artificial sun. Lastly, don’t make the mistake of getting a tiny tank just because your baby turtle looks small now. An adult needs 10 gallons for every inch of their shell.

Additionally, you must feed your turtle a varied diet. Since turtles are omnivores they need a little of this and a little of that in order to stay healthy. For meat, that means feeder insects or fish along with commercial pellets. Never source these from the wild as you might bring diseases in with the food. In terms of fruits and veggies, provide collard greens and bananas as supplements. Most importantly, mix it up so they never get sick of eating the same meal.

Person feeds their pet turtle
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Why is turtle ownership tricky?

While there are wonderful aspects of taking care of this ancient creature, a few things stand out that make turtle ownership uniquely difficult.

They live a long time

And we mean really long. Some large tortoise species have supposedly made it to their second century (though there’s some doubt about the veracity of those claims). We can confirm centenarian turtles though. Keep in mind the species you keep as pets will almost certainly not live to see the 22nd century. You’re looking at likely 40 years and even 50 in some species. Yes, that means your scaly friend may very well outlive you. People actually do will their water-loving pets to family members, similarly inclined friends, or specific rescue groups who are able to place them. No one likes thinking about the end of their lives, but it’s crucial that we prepare for our pets if we are no longer able to provide care. Taking in an animal means committing for life, and sometimes that’s their life span and not yours. 

Turtles can carry disease

Many turtles carry salmonella and have made their humans very sick after contracting it. While it doesn’t harm the reptile, salmonella can easily pass to you while feeding, handling, or cage cleaning. It’s crucial that you wash your hands every single time you come into contact with your aquatic pet. Because of this, you might limit touching or holding her and instead enjoy watching your creature. For people with compromised immune systems, even with precautions it probably isn’t safe, and you will likely need to select a different pet. 

Don’t let these things discourage you with enough careful planning and proper safety measures, a pet turtle can be the ideal addition to your home. They are fun to watch and interesting to learn about. Some owners have even successfully taught their turtles basic tricks, and many show affection for their people in their own way. While not a conventional pet, for the right home they fit in just as well as any furry friend.

Editors' Recommendations

Rebekkah Adams
Rebekkah’s been a writer and editor for more than 10 years, both in print and digital. In addition to writing about pets…
Bunny care 101: If Easter inspires you to adopt a rabbit, read this first
These are the things you need to think about before you bring a rabbit home
Brown bunny sits in the grass

Around this time of year, you'll spot bunnies everywhere — in the yard, the grocery candy aisle, and on TV. You may suddenly find yourself thinking about owning one of these cute small pets, and before you know it, you've adopted and brought home a hoppy and floppy pet.

We generally don't recommend impulse purchases when it comes to animals, but if you find yourself walking away from a shelter or pet store with Peter Rabbit in hand, you'll need to brush up quickly. It takes a lot: housing, food, cleaning, playtime, grooming, and vet bills. Understanding each piece of the puzzle will allow you to flourish as a pet parent and help your four-legger to live their best life, too. Keep reading to learn more about owning a bunny.

Read more
Are female betta fish worth it? Here’s why you should consider getting one of these pretty fish
Unlike males, female betta fish can live together, and get along with other fish, too
A blue female betta in a tank

Betta fish (also known as Siamese fighting fish) rocketed to fame and took a spot as one of our favorite swimming pets for their beautiful color and elegant fins. They, too, are recognized for being aggressive toward each other and will even flare (a display) to you, their owner. However, many of those characteristics only apply to the males of the species, whereas the female versions look and act a little differently. Here's why you should consider bringing one of these lady bettas home.

What are betta fish?
These underwater beauties come from Thailand and live in rice paddies in the wild. It's a myth that they only need a small tank, but bettas often do make great solitary pets that can thrive in an aquarium by themselves. They can also live with many other fish, just not other bettas. One fun thing about these swimmers is that they learn to recognize their owners and will get excited when you come to feed them every night.
How do female bettas differ from males?
You probably know that you can't keep male bettas with others of their kind, as they will fight males and sometimes aggressively mate with females (we recommend only experts breed them). Female bettas won't likely be building any bubble nests though, as that's a job for the males.

Read more
Looking to add corydoras to your aquarium? Here’s what you need to know first
Read this before bringing home a cory catfish to add to your tank
Two cory catfish hang out on the bottom of the tank

One thing you might not know about aquariums until you get one: Every tank needs a janitor, which may wind up just being you. When you first dive into this hobby, it can take a while to realize how much maintenance is really involved — don't think that the filter will do all the work. But if you want a little a help in that department, you can add a catfish to the fray. If you don't have a ton of experience with these bottom feeders, we recommend one of the corydoras since they're generally best for beginners.

What are corydoras?
This is a type of catfish, but there are actually more than 170 species to choose from. These are a well-known group of swimmers who get their name from their barbels, which look a bit like whiskers. While you'll find dozens of options in the pet store, you will likely narrow it down quickly based on the size of your tank, temperature, habitat you've chosen, and the other fish that they'll live with eventually.
Are corydoras friendly?
Yes, corydoras are sweet and gentle fish. They particularly like spending time together, but get along with many others as well. In some cases, you should not buy just one as they'll get lonely. Instead grab a pair of the same type and watch them become best friends. You'll often see them as bottom feeders, well, at the base of the tank, but cory cats also come up to the surface for air or food from time to time.

Read more